The Financial Services Minister has confirmed the key legislative elements of the establishment of AFCA and the facts that the transition team, being led by Dr Malcolm Edey, will undertake stakeholder consultation in order to develop AFCA’s terms of reference, governance and funding arrangements. See Putting consumers first – improving dispute resolution

Key changes to the Bill

  • Strengthened governance – the Bill allows the Minister to appoint a minority of the AFCA board on its establishment, including the independent chair. This will ensure that the board has the necessary skills and expertise to deliver an improved EDR service.
  • Superannuation – key features of the SCT’s complaints handling model, including requirements for handling death benefit complaints, the decision-making test and the unlimited monetary jurisdiction, will be enshrined in the Bill, to provide certainty to stakeholders.
  • Transitional arrangements – the Bill will require membership of the FOS and CIO to be maintained for up to 12 months following AFCA’s commencement on 1 July 2018, to enable the orderly resolution of their outstanding disputes prior to cessation of the two schemes. In relation to superannuation disputes, from 1 July 2018 all new superannuation complaints will be lodged with AFCA. The SCT will continue to operate until 30 June 2020 in order to resolve its backlog of legacy complaints.
  • Transparency of internal dispute resolution (IDR) – to improve transparency and accountability of firms’ IDR practices, the Bill provides for ASIC to publish IDR data, including firm-level data that identifies firms.

Matters to be addressed in AFCA’s terms of reference

AFCA’s operating rules — known as its terms of reference (TOR) — will set out the way in which AFCA will meet its duties and requirements under the law and how it will operate, including:

  • monetary limits – the increased monetary limits and compensation caps for both small business credit facility and other non-superannuation disputes will be set out in AFCA’s TOR. In addition, the transition team will consult on sub-limits (such as for disputes about general insurance broking), for inclusion in AFCA’s TOR;
  • decision-making processes – AFCA will be required to take a consistent approach to decision-making so that consumers and financial firms know what to expect from AFCA;
  • internal dispute resolution requirements – before AFCA will consider a dispute it will refer all complaints back to the financial firm for a final opportunity to resolve the dispute in a defined timeframe (subject to certain exceptions), to ensure that the IDR process has the opportunity to work; and
  • an independent assessor – AFCA will have an independent assessor to investigate complaints regarding the way in which a dispute was handled, to ensure procedural fairness.

To ensure that AFCA is accountable for the fees it charges to members, as a condition of authorisation, AFCA will be required to report to the responsible Minister annually on any decisions to vary fees.

This reporting requirement, along with the requirement for independent reviews and the enhanced governance arrangements (including ASIC’s directions power, AFCA’s board structure, and the requirement for AFCA to establish an independent assessor), will ensure that AFCA is transparent and accountable to both industry and consumers.

Further details on changes to the Bill and matters AFCA will need to address in its TORs are in the Treasury fact sheet.


This document is designed to provide helpful general guidance on some key issues relevant to this topic. It should not be relied on as legal advice. It does not cover everything that may be relevant to you and does not take into account your particular circumstances. It is only current as at the date of release. You must ensure that you seek appropriate professional advice in relation to this topic as well as to the currency, accuracy and relevance of this material for you.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation. Legal practitioners of Radford Lawyers Pty Limited are members of the scheme.